To the despair of my most liberal friends, I stopped wearing masks indoors weeks ago, about two weeks after my second dose of the Pfizer vaccine, and well before the CDC updated their guidance that vaccinated individuals no longer need masks indoors. Also, I never really wore masks outside. As anyone who followed CopyrightBro throughout 2020 surely knows, this is not because I didn’t take the pandemic seriously, but because I trusted what the science said. I’m now wondering whether some of my friends actually care about the science or whether they used it as a convenient talking point in an elaborate game of identity politics disguised by a public health crisis.
Science is science and facts are facts, regardless of whether the CDC has publicly acknowledged them yet. The CDC obviously wants to be dealing in facts, but the truth is they also have to weigh the political effects and the real world outcomes of any announcements they make. Their credibility has been seriously shaken in the past year, so I think it makes sense for Americans to start making their own decisions based on the science, even if the CDC hasn’t given them those specific directions yet. By March, anyone with eyeballs could see that the vaccination campaign was moving at a good clip and that it wouldn’t be long before a majority of Americans were vaccinated. While it would take a bit longer to reach herd immunity, the risk of any one person catching COVID was quickly falling, and we also knew that the vaccines had extremely high efficacy. Vaccinated individuals who were truly motivated by science had practically nothing to fear, so it makes sense that they would do the math for themselves and decide that it was safe enough to start the process of getting back to normal (and leaving masks behind) even though the CDC hadn’t yet relaxed any of their recommendations.
Experts believe we need roughly 70-90% of adults to be vaccinated to reach herd immunity. My understanding is that we’re currently at about 60%, but we’re fighting an uphill battle because we’re now at the point where supply has outstripped demand; vaccinations rates are slowing because most of the people who wanted vaccines got them early, so we’re now dealing with the slower process of convincing those who were skeptical or hesitant that vaccines are safe and in their best interest. I doubt we’ll ever get more than 80-85% because a significant number of people now believe the rampant disinformation that’s been spread from antivaxxers and the far right (largely on Facebook and Fox News), but I do think there are a number of convincible people out there who just need a little more encouragement or incentive.
My decision to stop wearing a mask isn’t just some libertarian urge to get back to normal and stop letting the government “control my life,” which was a pretty stupid argument to begin with. The best reason for taking the masks off (aside from the fact that it is undeniably safe to do so) is that for those who are hesitant about vaccines, this could be the extra incentive they need to do their research and decide that it may be worth it for them to take the shots, provided that they can then also ditch their masks. Nobody really likes wearing them. They’re uncomfortable, they cause glasses to fog up, they force to you smell your own breath, and generally make breathing a bit less efficient. Seeing vaccinated people go in stores and conduct their lives like normal may be the best incentive we could come up with, for a lot of people.
The only counter argument to using freedom from masks as a vaccination incentive worth considering is that we would have no way to know for sure if someone is fully vaccinated, and whether they’re technically allowed to take their mask off just yet. I think the response to that argument is pretty straightforward: it doesn’t matter. As long as we don’t have any sort of vaccine passport (and that’s something I think the federal government needs to be looking into), it’s true that we can’t verify who’s been vaccinated and are therefore forced to rely on the honor system. But again, it doesn’t matter. The only people who are going to be hurt by people lying about their vaccination status are other people who are lying about their vaccination. If you’ve already been vaccinated, you really have no reason to fear a redneck Trump supporter who lied to the greeter at Walmart: the only people he’s going to hurt by spreading COVID in there are the other unvaccinated morons who lied to get past the greeter.
If you’re a liberal who has been vaccinated and you’re still desperately clinging to your mask despite the fact that the science says you have no realistic chance of getting COVID from the redneck in Walmart, you need to ask yourself if it was ever really about the science for you. I suspect it probably wasn’t. A disappointing number of people on the left seem to have entangled their political identity with mask wearing (as many on the right have done with their refusal to wear one), using masks as a way to virtue signal, wearing them proudly as a badge of their status as good, obedient liberals. If that’s what it’s about for those who claimed to be following the science, then it becomes a lot harder to blame those on the other side and those who are honestly skeptical of the science. The left accused Trump and the right of politicizing masks from the start, and while they were certainly guilty of that, the left wasn’t innocent: they were just more subtle. If you were using the science to shit on Republicans for not wearing mask six months ago, then you should expect them to use that same excuse to shit on you for continuing to wear masks now.
The bottom line: get your shots, ditch your mask.